Best Pizza in Newark

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Newark, OH at 340 Mt Vernon Rd

Thin Crust. Thick Loyalty.

Built Right Here in Newark

Alley Cat Subs & Pizza has been serving Newark from Mt. Vernon Road with thin-crust pizza, loaded subs, and prices that actually make sense — all made with care for the community we call home.

Order Now

Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱Tom Cat 🐱Fat Cat 🐱Thin Crust Fanatics 🐱Subs That Don't Cut Corners 🐱Owner-Made, Not Corporate-Baked 🐱

Subs Built the Right Way

The Italian sub has its own fan club. Stuffed, not skimped — it holds its own next to the pizza.

See Our Menu

Fresh Out the Oven

Visit Us Today!

Looking for great pizza, loaded subs, and friendly service in Newark? Visit Alley Cat Subs & Pizza on Mt. Vernon Road for fresh thin-crust pizzas, hearty portions, and hometown hospitality that keeps locals coming back.