Newark's Pizza Joint, No Shortcuts
Alley Cat is a neighborhood spot on Mt. Vernon Road — real food, real prices, and an owner who still hands you a free slice.
Alley Cat Subs & Pizza | Our Story
The Crust We're Known For
Thin, crispy, built to pull long ribbons of melted cheese — old-school pizza made with real pride, not a formula.
The Subs Are No Afterthought
The Italian sub earns its own loyal following — loaded, well-built, and stacked the way a real sub should be.
Prices That Feel Like a Gift
A 16-inch pepperoni and a half Italian sub for under twenty dollars — a deliberate choice, not a gimmick.
A Sign You Can Count On
That vintage cat on the pole isn't just a sign — it's a promise. Regulars are earned one order at a time.
